Tag Archives: modernist

Citizens denied voice at RPL mtg on Central Library

RPL Board denied the opportunity for FRPL and other citizens to make presentations to the RPL Board at a critical meeting about the future of Central Library.

The RPL’s draft agenda, posted on Friday July 14, for which citizens had only until Tuesday July 18 at noon to write a presentation and request to make a presentation, included:

8. Discussion and decision items

(a) Board Committees

iv) Strategic Planning Committee

(1)  Project Charter

(2)  Project Governance Terms of Reference

(3)  Colliers Statement of Work for Central Library Renewal Project

(4)  Colliers Statement of Work for Central Library Temporary Relocation Project

(5)  Branch renewal update

FRPL and other citizens sent in letters requesting to make presentations at the RPL Board meeting on July 25, 2023. In its letter FRPL restated our position that it would be better to expand on the new building, rather than tear it down and rebuild. We went on to ask questions about the criteria for future development and public participation processes. FRPL presentation FRPL to RPL Board July 18, 2023 – fina

On July 21 RPL sent the following email:

.. The topics represented in your submission do not align with topics on the agenda. The Library Board decision made in September 2022 is not under review and the Board’s work to move forward supports its decision to build a new Central Library, with a preference for the current location. The Library’s engagement of Colliers Project Leaders as its owner’s representative was undertaken over three years ago and is not under review. The Library Board does not have purview over how City Council allocates project funding. The many other topics you have included are not in question at this meeting.

As outlined in the Submissions and Delegations Policy, your submission will be included in the Board’s package for their information and later posted to the RPL website. …”

Similar emails were sent in response to Jeannie Mah RPL Board. July 2023 and Florence Stratton LIBRARY BOARD, CENTRAL LIBRARY, JULY 25 2023

The RPL Board continues its efforts to restrict public discussion of its decisions or future plans. Unlike City Council, the RPL Board does not release any details in advance about its agenda items. Reports given at the “public meetings” are not published along with the minutes. The minutes only appear publicly over 2 months after the meetings, after they are approved by the RPL Board at its subsequent meeting, then eventually posted on their website.

NEVERTHELESS, CITIZENS ARE URGED TO ATTEND THE NEXT RPL BOARD MEETING ON JLUY 25 AT 4:30 PM. Check details on the day of the meeting to confirm. https://www.reginalibrary.ca/about/leadership/board-meetings-2023

  • In person, at the RPL Boardroom on the second floor of Central Library..
  • Via Microsoft Teams – you must email the RPL in advance to be included on the list.
  • Or by teleconference: check the RPL agenda for the conference call-in number and password.

Central plans at RPL Board July 25 – make your views known

RPL is moving ahead with plans to demolish Central and rebuild. Plans will be discussed at their July 25 Board meeting.  Draft agenda 0-Draft Agenda – posting 20230714 Go to the RPL website for the final agenda. https://www.reginalibrary.ca/about/leadership/board-meetings-2023

Requests for presentation to the July 25 Board meeting must be in by Tues. July 18 at 12 noon. https://reginalibrary.ca/about/leadership/presenting-to-the-board

Recent developments:

Please express your views by:

  • Sending in a letter, and a request for submission, to RPL Board by Tues. July 18 at 12 noon
  • Sending letters or email or phoning the RPL Board and your City Councillors
  • Attending the July 25 RPL Board meeting. to hear what the plans are for Central. This can be done in person, connecting by hone, or connecting through Microsoft Teams. You need to register in advance for connecting to Microsoft Teams, and also download the software. In-person: Central Library Boardroom
    Online: email librarydirectorsoffice@reginalibrary.ca for Microsoft Teams link
    Dial-in: 1 (647) 749-9317, meeting passcode 183 336 408#

Demolition of Central would have to be approved by

  • Regina City Council
  • Saskatchewan Heritage Properties Review Board (because Central is part of the Victoria Park Heritage Conservation District)
  • What are the prospective timelines and/or deadlines?
  • How does the RPL Board justify the destruction of a heritage building?

Concerns and possible questions from FRPL

  • RPL Board interpretation and reporting to City Council of cost estimates inaccurate for upgrading the current building, resulting in claims that it is not possible to rehabilitate the building
  • Maintaining the current building
  • Preserving its heritage
  • Specifics about including preservation of heritage in the requests for proposals to architects
  • Costs of relocation (budget for the move, budget for the demolition and budget for new construction). Will there be financials in the statement of work documents?
  • What are the plans and timeline for securing the money for any changes?
  • Changes to current situation should not be approved until clear plans are in place.  We all know of the projects recently that have collapsed after the initial fanfare, think Centre Pointe and Namerind.  What contingencies are in place for unforeseen delays or overrun budgets?
  • When will project management reports, such as those being discussed at the July 25, 2023 meeting, be available to the public? (project charter and the two statements of work)
  • Colliers has been hired to project manage both the temporary relocation project and the rebuild.  What expertise and experience has Colliers got that give the public confidence about their competence, especially in new construction?
  • Does the Library Board do this directly or through a subcommittee of the Board?
  • How much is the City of Regina involved, such as a city project manager? What is the “chain of command” and where does the final accountability reside? Will there be opportunities for the public to review and comment on decisions throughout the process?
  • What are the plans for public consultation?  Will there be regular opportunities for engagement and the ability to question plans?  Will a public design charette be used to engage and explore how this rebuild will fit with the public’s expertise and knowledge of building design and desired uses of libraries? How will the disability community and individuals or those with specialized needs be engaged throughout the process?
  • Will this rebuild be a net-zero carbon building?  What opportunities will there be to capture or reduce the carbon footprint of this rebuild?  Will this be put into the request for proposals?

Nov 10 (revised) deadline for Catalyst Ctte submissions

Members of the public have until Nov 10 at midnight to
1. Fill out the Be Heard Survey https://beheard.regina.ca/catalyst-committee
2. Submit comments to the Catalyst Committee.. 

Send to:  Attention Co-chairs Tim Reid + Bob Hawkins at catalyst@regina.ca and

Cc: Regina City Council Clerks at clerks@regina.ca  – to forward to Mayor and all Council
      RPL Board therplboard@reginalibrary.ca – to forward to all Board members
 

Modernist Central Library – why it should be preserved

An excellent display by Jeannie Mah to the Catalyst Committee about the value of the modernist Central Library Building. Modernist Central Library. J. Mah

Speaking notes for her Oct. 20, 2022 presentation to the Catalyst Committee. Notes. Modernist Central Library, for Catalyst C. J. MAH

Also Jeannie Mah’s presentation to the RPL Board on Sept. 27 RPL Board Central Library_27th Sept 2022

Our Modernist Central Library was built in 1962 after winning a city-wide plebiscite vote to spend $925,000 for a new library. Sixty years later, with neither discussion paper nor public discussion nor mention of its Heritage status, the RPL Library Board has “considered what’s best for customers and the community”, and has voted to demolish Central Library.

Tours of Central: Oct 25 to 29

Regina Public Library is hosting tours from Oct 25 to 29, 2022 “to share information about the history of the building and some of the issues we are facing. Join us for a guided tour to hear about key concerns and remediation RPL has been undertaking to keep it safe. There will be opportunity to ask questions along the way. This tour provides a chance to learn more about the Central Library Renewal (CLR) project, one of the infrastructure projects being reviewed by the City of Regina’s Catalyst Committee. Tours begin in the lobby and will last approximately one hour. Tues, Oct 25 2:00pm – 3:00pm, Wed, Oct 26 2:00pm – 3:00pm, Wed, Oct 26 6:00pm – 7:00pm, Thurs, Oct 27 6:00pm – 7:00pm, Sat, Oct 29 10:00am – 11:00am For more information, and to register for a tour: https://central.reginalibrary.ca/” You must preregister – have your library card handy or be prepared to sign up for one.

Note that these tours are supposed to talk about the heritage aspects of the building, but their main focus will be on the problems with the building, to justify the RPL Board’s decision to tear it down. So be prepared for this line of thought, and your questions about the building.

Deadline Oct 31st: letters to Catalyst Committee

Deadline Oct 31st:  Send presentations that were given to the RPL Board, presentations given at Catalyst Committee and other thoughts to Catalyst Committee.  

It has been suggested to us that it would be good to have your presentations and letters sent to the Catalyst Committee by the end of October.

Send to:  Attention Co-chairs Tim Reid + Bob Hawkins at catalyst@regina.ca and

Tim Reid at tim.reid@real1884.ca and dakota.schmidt@real1884.ca 

Bob Hawkins at  bhawkins@regina.ca 


Cc: Regina City Council Clerks at clerks@regina.ca  – to forward to Mayor and all Council.

Public can listen, present at Catalyst Ctte

Reminder of this week’s meetings of the Catalyst Committee. See important articles and letters to the editor https://friendsofrpl.ca/central-branch-2021/media-coverage-central-library-2022/

Information on the Catalyst Committee https://beheard.regina.ca/catalyst-committee Regina Residents Invited to Provide Input on Once-in-a-Generation Catalyst Committee Projects, October 7, 2022 https://www.regina.ca/news/Regina-Residents-Invited-to-Provide-Input-on-Once-in-a-Generation-Catalyst-Committee-Projects/

Their report to Council in January 2023 will have a major influence on projects that will receive City Council support in the future.

Sessions Oct. 17 to 20, 11 am to 1 pm and 5 pm to 7 pm
AGT Lounge, enter by Northwest door at Mosaic Stadium. Use Elevator 2 to the 3rd floor.
Parking in nearby lots, bus #12

Project proponents will make first presentation of about 30 minutes.
Members of the public can make presentations, 5 to 10 minutes is suggested, but there is no set time limit. You don’t have to submit your presentation in advance. You can bring PowerPoint presentations on a USB stick.

Monday: Multi-Purpose Event Centre
Tuesday: Regina Aquatics Centre
Wednesday: Multi-Purpose Outdoor Baseball Event Centre & Synthetic Outdoor Field Project (joint presentation)
Thursday: Modernization of the Central Library

People can sent in emails / letters to the Catalyst Committee.
 For full consideration, get them in by the end of October. Email questions and submissions to clerks@regina.ca with the subject line  “Catalyst Committee”.

The BEHEARD survey will be posted on the City of Regina website (www.beheard.regina.ca/catalyst-committee) starting on October 17th.  

There is no arrangement for broadcasting the event on the internet, so no ability to make a presentation remotely or to hear what is being said.

People can create display storyboards, to be at the AGT location by Friday Oct 14 or befor 11 am on the 17th

There is no downtown location for a discussion of the downtown.

Library at Catalyst Committee Oct. 20th

Just posted by the City of Regina on Friday at 2:30 (ish) pm before the long weekend, a media release outlining the “opportunity” of 4 hours time to comment on the RPL proposal about Central Library. This Committee will make recommendations to the City of Regina about City support of major projects, including Central Library. 

Regina Residents Invited to Provide Input on Once-in-a-Generation Catalyst Committee Projects, October 7, 2022

https://www.regina.ca/news/Regina-Residents-Invited-to-Provide-Input-on-Once-in-a-Generation-Catalyst-Committee-Projects/

  • Consultations will be from 11 am to 1 pm and 5 to 7 pm from Oct. 17 to 20
  • Central Library will be discussed on Oct. 20
  • People can go there and make a presentation – apparently a 30-minute time limit.
  • Currently there is no arrangement for broadcasting the event on the internet, so no ability to make a presentation or to hear what is being said.
  • People can create display storyboards for display, to be at the AGT location by Friday Oct 14 (presumably at close of the business day?).
  • There is no downtown location for a discussion of the downtown.
  • There will be a BEHEARD survey on the City of Regina website (www.beheard.regina.ca/catalyst-committee) starting on October 17th.  
  • You can currently send them questions now. 
  • In an interview with Paul Dechene of Prairie Dog Magazine, Councillor Hawkins, co-chair of the Catalyst Committee, said they will be accepting written submissions.  Written submissions or questions should be emailed to clerks@regina.ca with the subject line as Catalyst Committee.
  • Paul Dechene’s Oct. 6th interview “Catalyst Committee Interview With Councillor Hawkins” where the goals of the Committee are explained. Queen City Improvement Bureau Podcasts  http://queencityib.com/podcasts/2022/10/7/oct-07-2022-catalyst-committee-interview-with-councillor-hawkins

Actions to preserve Central Library

We would encourage the preservation of Heritage and Rehabilitation of RPL’s Central Library, a more environmental and less costly solution. https://friendsofrpl.ca/central-branch-2021/why-retaining-buildings-is-a-better-plan/

Examples of rehabilitation and additions to library buildings https://friendsofrpl.ca/central-branch-2021/library-additions-examples/ 

URGENT!  Express your views:

  1. Letters to the Editor in Leader Post. Send to: letters@LeaderPost.com.  250 word limit.  Name and phone number. Send to national papers.
  2. Letters, emails or phone calls to the Mayor and all City Councillors https://www.regina.ca/about-regina/contact-us/contact-councillor/   or contact City Clerks clerks@regina.ca Clerks Office will forward emails, including longer ones, PDFs, or documents with photos that don’t fit into the online form. Mayor Masters and Councillor Findura are also on the RPL Board, and voted against the RPL Board motion. Councillor Hawkins is co-chair of the Catalyst Committee. Phone numbers and contact information for City Councillors CITY COUNCILLORS CONTACT INFO – Oct. 3, 2022
  3. Letters, emails or phone calls to the RPL Board therplboard@reginalibrary.ca , or by post to: Regina Public Library, CEO’s Office, 2311 12th Avenue, Regina, SK S4P 3Z5
  4. Send questions and comments or comment online to programs such as CBC Morning Edition, and other local news TV and radio shows.
  5. Are you willing to be interviewed by the media – many voices make light work!
  6. Contact other groups, organizations or individuals who could help address this issue.
  7. Please forward copies of your letters to FRPL, and let us know if we have your permission to share on our website and on our Facebook page. frpl@sasktel.net
  8. Attend the Catalyst Committee’s public consultations, to be held in October.

Library additions around the world

There have been many libraries that have rehabilitated and expanded their space, showing that we can also do this in Regina, preserving our heritage modernist building, while enhancing the library. These are some examples.

Moose Jaw Public Library

Winnipeg Millennium Library https://winnipegarchitecture.ca/251-donald-street/

The Patkau rehabilitation of the 1967 Winnipeg Centennial Library. https://www.patkau.ca/projects/winnipeg-millennium-library

          Completed in 2005 for $21-million, the Patkau expansion of the Winnipeg Millennium Library added 3,700 square metres (40,000 sq ft) of new space, construction of a new fourth floor, and renovations throughout the existing 10,000-square-metre (110,000 sq ft) library.

          Awards: General’s Medal in Architecture (2008); Lieutenant-Governor’s Medal in Architecture (2007); Prairie Design Award (2006); and the Canadian Architect Award of Excellence (2004).

Edmonton Library https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/edmonton/edmonton-public-library-reopening-1.5724880 and video https://www.epl.ca/milner-library/   $85 million.

Renos and refurbishments in Toronto libraries https://www.torontopubliclibrary.ca/renovations/

Runnymede $3.3 million expansion. 2006.Design Excellence Award  (2007)Ontario Association of Architects   https://www.strattonarchitects.com/runnymede-public-library

Bloor/Gladstone District Library https://www.rdharch.com/bloor-gladstone-library-1 and https://www.archdaily.com/133796/the-bloorgladstone-library-rdh-architects

           “The Bloor/Gladstone Branch library project is a renovation and addition to a listed heritage library in downtown Toronto. The architects were commissioned to design for an additional 12,000 sqf, bringing the collection and facilities to a level consistent with that of a Toronto District Library. The final design includes major renovations to the existing building as well as the construction of an addition.” 2009.

Robarts Library, University of Toronto https://dsai.ca/projects/robarts-common/ and https://dailyhive.com/toronto/u-of-t-robarts-library-expansion-renderings ( add 50,000 sq ft.)

          “With ample natural light, room for 1,200 students to study in quiet or socialize in soundproofed rooms, and accessible spaces for the entire U of T community, Robarts Common is a human-centred, collaborative area. Opening in advance of the 50th anniversary of Robarts Library, Robarts Common is part of a wider revitalization of the iconic building in the heart of U of T’s downtown campus.”     https://defygravitycampaign.utoronto.ca/news-and-stories/official-opening-of-robarts-common/

OCAD University (Ontario College of Art and Design), Toronto https://all.design/willalsop/ocad

          Another possibility would be to build up on the west lot and partially over the current building. The addition by architect Will Alsop to the Ontario College of Art is a striking example of what could be done. Described as a flying box-on-legs” it definitely has a “buzzy vibe” (link to site -Will Alsop on 10 Years of OCAD U’s Sharp Centre for Design) https://www.designlinesmagazine.com/will-alsop-10-years/ .

Hamilton Central Library https://www.rdharch.com/hamilton-central-library-and-farmers-market-1.

          “This major renovation in downtown Hamilton rejuvenates the existing facility through the reorganisation of both program elements: the first two stories are re-clad in glazed curtain wall while an addition is placed at the northwest corner to reconfigure the main entry. The resulting transparent, glowing, horizontal slab reconnects the library to the market and to the new street edge, projecting the life and vitality of the library and market the city and its inhabitants. “

          Awards: 2014 Chicago Athenaeum International Award of Excellence, 2012 Ontario Library Association Award of Excellence, 2012 Canadian Interiors Best of Canada Award2011 OAA Award for Design Excellence, 2011 Design Exchange National Bronze Medal,2009 Canadian Architect Awards of Excellence Notable Mention.

The Morgan Library and Museum, New York https://www.themorgan.org/architecture/renzo-piano/expansion

Boston Library https://rawnarch.com/projects/bpl-boylston.html

Beyazit State Library, Istanbul, Turkey https://www.archdaily.com/791885/beyazit-state-library-tabanlioglu-architects

OTHER BUILDING ADDITIONS

Watari Museum of Art, built on a 600 square meter site (about the same size as the Central Library west lot) with 6 floors giving 3600 sq. meters of space. http://www.watarium.co.jp/en/ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Watari_Museum_of_Contemporary_Art